Nominations Clarifications #1

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you for your patience as tags are being approved.

Please don’t forget to add disambiguations to your relationships/characters. To prevent confusion over wandering tags, nothing without a disambiguation will be approved. I’m adding disambiguations to some, but it’s going slow as these nominations are not given priority due to formatting. 

There are no rejections, but it might seem so from your end. I had to edit some tags that were approved, and AO3 lets you do that by removing the original tag from the tagset. If your nomination was rejected and does not appear in the tagset, please let me know. If it was edited to be something you did not intend, let me know. For both cases, please link to your nomination and let me know which nomination to fix.

If there’s anything in the tagset that needs changing, like characters/relationships that have wandered, typos, trope categories to be added to/removed from a freeform, etc, let me know here.




Clarifications

Relationships/Characters

Star Wars - All Media Types

Obi-Wan Kenobi/Siri Tachi (Star Wars - All Media Types)
Qui-Gon Jinn/Obi-Wan Kenobi (Star Wars - All Media Types)

Star Wars - All Media Types is not allowed as a fandom. What specific fandoms do these characters belong to? Prequels, Originals, Sequels, Rogue One, Rebels, etc? Are they a crossover between fandoms?

Freeform Tags

Freeform tags for a fandom need to be prefaced with the fandom name.

Example:

MCU: Staying under the ice for so long deserums Steve so he’s skinny again

Are these fandom specific? If so, what fandom do they belong to?

• Trans man Sherlock Holmes - which Holmes fandom?
• Ruffians in the Shire - is this LOTR Books? LOTR Movies? The Hobbit?
• blackthorn family can turn into dragons - What is the fandom?
• Killer Batman - What fandom does this Batman belong to?
• Cowboy Carey Price - is this Men’s Hockey RPF?
• Nonbinary My Unit | Byleth - is this for Fire Emblem: Fuukasetsugetsu | Fire Emblem: Three Houses? Is “Fire Emblem Three Houses” ok?

Comments

[primeideal]

Not the nominator, but Qui-Gon/Obi-Wan are usually found under Prequels fandom! (There might be a specific legends/EU property that this nominator wanted, though.)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you so much!

[(Anonymous)]

"blackthorn family can turn into dragons" is for Pokemon Adventures

"Cowboy Carey Price" is Men's Hockey RPF

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you! I've added them.

[shadaras]

Not the nominator, but I can at least partially answer about the Star Wars ships:

Obi-Wan Kenobi/Siri Tachi is from Star Wars Legends. I don't know how specific you or the nominator would want to get, but the specific series canonical on Ao3 for it is probably either "Star Wars Legends: Jedi Apprentice Series - Jude Watson & Dave Wolverton" or "Star Wars Legends: Jedi Quest Series - Jude Watson".

I have no idea which version of Obi-Wan/Qui-Gon the nominator would want, but it's probably either Prequels or either New/Legends EU.

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you so much!

[(Anonymous)]

You're right! I'm the nominator for Star Wars ships, and I did mean for them to be like this:

Obi-Wan Kenobi/Siri Tachi (Star Wars Legends: Jedi Quest Series - Jude Watson)
Obu-Wan Kenobi/Qui-Gon Jinn (Star Wars Prequel Trilogy)

Sorry for the confusion, mods!

[minoanmiss]

Sorry, "Ruffians in the Shire" is mine. It belongs to LOTR Books.

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you so much! I've added it.

[(Anonymous)]

We have one misfiled ship in the fandom 魔道祖师 - 墨香铜臭 | Módào Zǔshī - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù

The ship Jiāng Chéng | Jiāng Wǎnyín/Liǔ Qīnggē (MDZS) is actually a crossover with one of the author's other works, 人渣反派自救系统 - 墨香铜臭 | The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù

To match other things in the Crossover Fandom section, the corrected tag should be Jiāng Chéng | Jiāng Wǎnyín (MDZS)/Liǔ Qīnggē (SVSSS)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you! I've changed it.

[(Anonymous)]

I nominated Malik Al-Sayf/Altaïr Ibn-La'Ahad/Maria Thorpe for the fandom Assassin’s Creed, but it looks as though it was changed to a second Desmond Miles/Lucy Stillman nomination. Renominating just leads to a duplicate nomination error. These are completely different characters even with the way the series handles ancestry/memories/whatever.

[hauntedshadow]

Sorry about that! I've added Malik Al-Sayf/Altaïr Ibn-La'Ahad/Maria Thorpe.

[(Anonymous)]

Hi, I noticed a duplicate in Final Fantasy XIV:
Alphinaud Leveilleur/Estinien Wyrmblood (FFIV)
Alphinaud Leveilleur/Estinien Wyrmblood (Final Fantasy XIV)
These are the same, I'm not sure why someone is putting FFIV on FFXIV things.

[(Anonymous)]

I've spotted a couple of duplicates/typos:

Original Works:
Husband & Wife Supervillain Team/Captured Superheroine (OW)
Husband & Wife Supervillain Team/Captured Superhoerine (OW)

Freeforms:
Hurt/Confort - rape recovery
Noncon - Rape Recovery

[(Anonymous)]

Different anon from the original poster but just adding on another typo:

phraim/Seth (Fire Emblem: Sacred Stones) - instead of Ephraim

[(Anonymous)]

Also different anon, I found another duplicate:
Face-Fucking and FaceFucking in the freeforms.

[(Anonymous)]

Typo:

For the fandom バクダン★ハンダン | Bakudan Handan | Sweet Fuse: At Your Side
Inafune Sake & Shidou Subaru (Sweet Fuse) - should be 'Inafune Saki' instead of 'Inafune Sake'

[jack_of_none]

Couple issues:

-- All of my FFXIV pairing nominations had (FFIV) appended to the end of them, which is the wrong fandom. I'm not sure if I screwed up here or if it was added afterwards, but it should be FFXIV or Final Fantasy XIV

-- I somehow ended up with 2 nominations of the same pairing accepted in Gatchaman Crowds. I obviously meant to nominate 2 different pairings, but my nomination can't be edited now because of the double pairing. I know it's close to nominations closing so I'm not too concerned about getting the other pairing nominated, but the double pairing at least should probably be removed.

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you for point out the typo!

If you have any other nominations you want, please link to your nominations and let me know what you want to be added.

[jack_of_none]

Sorry this is late: My nomination is here

https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/3515/nominations/139060

One of the "Berg Katse/Ninomiya Rui" nominations under Gatchaman Crowds should be "Berg Katse/Ichinose Hajime/Ninomiya Rui" and if you get the chance I'd like "Ichinose Hajime/Ninomiya Rui" added as well.

All of the nominations under Final Fantasy XIV should have that fandom appended to them instead of FFIV (which I also nominated, but it's a different game).

[(Anonymous)]

There's a typo in one of my noms - "female Alpha with knitting cock" instead of "female Alpha with knotting cock."

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you so much! I had to remove it and change it with A/B/O - Female Alpha with knotting cock.