idproquo | Nominations clarification post #1

Nominations are pouring in! Our heartfelt thanks to everyone who removed piping, added disambiguation, and correctly formatted nominations. If you spot errors or duplicates, please let us know.

Fandoms

Thanks to a nonny's excellent suggestion, we have added a fandom called Any Fandom I've Requested for IPQ Before; the rules for nominating and requesting in that fandom are the same as for Any Fandom I've Requested Before.

The Lord of the Rings (Movies) - The nominations under this fandom are disambiguated "LOTR - AMT". Did you mean to nominate The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types? Please adjust your nomination so the fandom and the disambiguation match.

DCU - Comics - Forgive our ignorance, but are "DCU" and "DCU - Comics" the same? Some nominations in this fandom have one disambiguation and some have the other. Also, please check approved nominations to make sure you're not nominating a ship that's already approved.

Relationships

Please remove piping from nominations in the following fandoms, or let us know if it's needed for disambiguation:

19th Century CE RPF Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (TV 2018) Detroit: Become Human (Video Game) Elementary (TV) Final Fantasy VI La Dame de Monsoreau - Alexandre Dumas Marvel Cinematic Universe Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series) The Sandman (TV 2022) The Witcher (TV) Wiedźmin | The Witcher (Video Game)

When nominating in a fandom with multiple similarly named canons, please disambiguate with the name of the specific canon, e.g., Witcher TV rather than The Witcher.

MCU nominator of Catboy!Loki/Dogboy!Thor, we admire your creativity, but please put this in as a freeform and nominate Loki/Thor as usual.

Original Work nominators:

- Nomination formatting in this exchange is a little different from most other exchanges. Please check the rules and make sure your nominations are formatted correctly.

- If you nominated ships with multiple genders, please specify gender for each character unless the language of the nomination is inherently gendered. We assume an heiress is female and a widower is male, but words such as rogue, gold-digger, knight, socialites, and demon are unclear. The FM prefix is used for both Male Character/Female Character and Female Character/Male Character ships. Use any if you don't care what gender the character is.

Other: Reclusive Witch & Wizard Sent to Kill Her & Orphans Abandoned In The Woods (OW) - Please add genders and clarify whether the wizard has been sent to kill both the witch and the orphans, or only the witch.

Freeforms

Facials - Please clarify what sort of facial you mean.

~~The getaway weekend of our discontent - Please clarify what is meant by this.~~

~~Non-con - "do it before they do" - Please clarify what is meant by this. Are you aiming for something like "Prisoner A must noncon Prisoner B or captors will noncon them both"?~~

Soulmates have marks of those a soulmate cheated on; find third because there is no cheating mark - We're struggling to parse this. Can you clarify? We're happy to help you workshop it to keep it under 100 characters.

Threaded | Top-Level Comments Only

Soulmates have marks of those a soulmate cheated on; find third because there is no cheating mark - my reasoning is as follows:
soulmates have marks on them if their soulmate cheated and those marks are the names of whoever the soulmate cheated with (cheating being sexual encounters with anyone but one's soulmate, and yes, could be a partner, because in such a version one cannot be certain before having sex)
one part of a ship (A) goes and has sex with a third person (C)
other part (B) knows sex has occured (its up to the author how knowledgeable B is, but I do have ships where one partner allows another to seek sex elsewhere), but there is no mark, so C is another soulmate
I was trying to fit into the limit, so any clarifications are welcome
(the concept was mentioned in a tumblr post I have no hopes of finding, so there is no way of checking if there was a clearer wording)

The getaway weekend of our discontent: I turned it in the hopefully clearer "Couple Goes on Weekend Getaway & All Their Problems Explode"

Added the genders for Multi: Adoring Married Couple (any)/Ravishing Outsider Who Comes and Goes (any) (OW) and Multi: Rich Charming Married Socialites (FM)/Happless Man They Bring Into Relationship (OW). Sorry about the other FM ones - since one of the words in each of those was gendered, I assumed there was no need to clarify the gender in the other one.

What a cool concept! Would this work?

A Has Sex With B; If B Is Not A's Soulmate Then A's Soulmate C Is Marked With B's Name

That sets up the premise, and then you can prompt for the type of story you want.

Yes, it would fit, thank you!

Can you please be more specific on "Detroit: Become Human", because "Upgraded Connor | RK900" is its official archive name. I’m not exactly sure what you want. Thanks!

Edited 2023-01-02 16:38 (UTC)

Duplicates:

Wednesday (TV Show):
Wednesday Addams/Enid Sinclair (Wednesday 2022)
Wednesday Addams/Enid Sinclair (Wednesday)

Yu-Gi-Oh! (Anime and Manga):
Bakura Ryou/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM)
Bakura Ryou/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM)
Honda Hiroto/Jounouchi Katsuya/Kaiba Seto/Otogi Ryuuji (YGO DM)
Honda Hiroto/Jounouchi Katsuya/Kaiba Seto/Otogi Ryuuji (YGO DM)
Jounouchi Katsuya/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM)
Jounouchi Katsuya/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM)
Kaiba Gozaburo/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM)
Kaiba Gozaburo/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM)
Kaiba Mokuba/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM)
Kaiba Mokuba/Kaiba Seto (YGO DM

Edited 2023-01-02 16:44 (UTC)

Many canonical names in AO3 have piping that makes them difficult to read and takes up a lot of room in the tagset, so we ask that you pick just one name. We'll use "RK900" for those nominations.

Thanks, fixed!

I meant facials as in cum on someone's face. it's a canonical tag; it didn't occur to me that someone might read it in the spa sense.

There's a significant cohort of IPQ participants who are very into personal grooming, so we thought there was some potential for confusion there. Would you be amenable to clarifying it as Facials (Come) or similar?

Got it! Thanks! I just noticed it was accepted as is. Thank you for the clarification. First time I've heard of "piping". Good to know!

Np! It looked like the YGO! section just glitched out for a moment, hah.

Edited 2023-01-02 20:03 (UTC)

sure, that's fine!

Cobra Kai (TV Show):
Johnny Lawrence & Anthony LaRuso & Daniel LaRusso (Cobra Kai)

Anthony LaRuso supposed to be spelled as Anthony LaRusso

Thanks!

The Sandman (TV Show);
Delirium of the Endless & Dream of the Endless | Morpheus (The Sandman)

Delirium doesn’t appear in season 1 and there’s only one season. Neil has confirmed Delirium will be in season 2, but as right now they haven’t made an appearance.

Not sure if this is a problem. Just wanted to bring it to light for future picks.

https://ew.com/tv/neil-gaiman-says-delirium-is-coming-in-the-sandman-season-2/

Edited 2023-01-03 01:43 (UTC)

The LOTR - AMT noms were meant to be "All Media Types" but when I went to change them they'd already been approved - should I just re-nominate?

I know we're discouraged from nominating under AMT, but I can't think of a better way to flag "i don't mind if you're relying solely on movie canon"

I'm not entirely sure I know what I'm asking here, other than possibly for advice, possibly alerting you to my own screw up.

I nominated Boba Fett/Fennec Shand under Star Wars: The Book of Boba Fett. I forgot to disambiguate, but it got accepted.

I've now noticed that Boba Fett/Fennec Shand is also under all three of theses fandoms: The Mandalorian, Star Wars Original Trilogy, and Star Wars Prequel Trilogy. I don't know if someone else nominated that pairing under those fandoms, or if it was a result of my disambiguation screw up.

Uh. Mostly I'm asking because I don't know what to do as far as requesting the pairing if it stays under all four. If other people want it there, great, I'll figure it out. I just wanted to make sure it wasn't my boo boo.

...and I didn't realize I was logged out.

Fixed, thank you!

Thanks! We've decided to leave it in the tagset, since this is IPQ we're erring on the side of being lenient when it comes to what people want to request/offer.

I've moved the nominations to LOTR - AMT. Thanks for bringing it to our attention!

Sorry, that was our screwup! I've removed the tag from the additional three fandoms, so now it should only show up under Star Wars: The Book of Boba Fett.

Thank you!

...on the other hand, dang it! I was really hoping someone else was super excited about Boba/Fennec. 😆

Np!

Got ya! Thanks for the clarification!

It’s still showing up as misspelled.

Just spotted a few duplicates browsing the freeform section:

1) "Alternate Universe – BDSM" appears twice, I'm guessing with different versions of the - character

2) probably "complicated feelings of love and resentment and loyalty and hurt" and "Complicated relationships of love and loyalty and hurt and resentment" are two people trying to nominate the same recurring freeform, idk if the feelings/relationship phrasing difference means you want to keep them both....

Nominations clarification post #1

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

Duplicate Tagset

no subject

Re: Duplicate Tagset

re: facials

Re: facials

no subject

Re: Duplicate Tagset

Re: facials

Tagset Misspelling

Doesn’t Appear Yet

no subject

no subject

no subject

Re: Tagset Misspelling

Re: Doesn’t Appear Yet

no subject

no subject

no subject

Re: Tagset Misspelling

Re: Doesn’t Appear Yet

Re: Tagset Misspelling

couple of freeform dupes