Nominations Clean Up

[hauntedshadow]

Everything's been approved! Now is time for clean up! This will occur until January 28th at 10PM UTC.

There are no rejections, but it might seem so from your end. I had to edit some tags that were approved, and AO3 lets you do that by removing the original tag from the tagset. If your nomination was rejected and does not appear in the tagset, please let me know. If it was edited to be something you did not intend, let me know. For both cases, please link to your nomination and let me know which nomination to fix.

 

If there’s anything in the tagset that needs changing, like characters/relationships that have wandered, typos, trope categories to be added to/removed from a freeform, etc, let me know here.

Something to note:

There are tags that look like duplicates, but in this exchange, they are not considered duplicates. For example:

• Hurt/Comfort - Rape Recovery
• Noncon - Rape Recovery
• Rape Recovery

These are not considered duplicates because the trope prefix gives context to what lens the rape recovery is to be viewed under. Perhaps Hurt/Comfort is focusing on blankets and hugs, while Noncon involves graphic flashbacks to the rape. Rape Recovery as a standalone tag is free to be interpreted in whatever iddy way the recipient would like. Since ids are a vortex, there are many ways to interpret this standalone tag.

This is not to say that tags with prefixes cannot be redundant. Do not hesitate to mention tags that seem redundant. However, these tags might remain in the tagset if they're not considered duplicates because of the prefix affecting iddiness.

Comments

[primeideal]

Original works:

Husband & Wife Supervillain Team/Captured Superheroine (OW)
Husband & Wife Supervillain Team/Captured Superhoerine (OW)

first one appears correct, latter is typo?

New King Grieving & Besieged/Her Badass Bisexual Harem (Original Work)
New Queen Grieving & Besieged/Her Badass Bisexual Harem (Original Work)

Given that these are both in the tagset, should the first one be "His" Harem?

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Reposting from here https://idproquo.dreamwidth.org/2095.html?thread=23855#cmt23855

I think something on AO3 glitched when approving ships, since a Designed Survivor 60 Days ship (Jung Soo-Jung/Cha Young-Jin/Kim Nam-Wook/Park Soo-Kyo) appears also under MCU other than under the correct fandom.

I've mistyped a freeform tag, can it be fixed? It's "Accidental Marriage - Married to Each Other While Undercover Becomes Being Legally Binding"

It should be either "Being" or "Becomes", whichever sounds best (becomes?).

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you! I changed it to "Bomes Legally Binding."

[(Anonymous)]

Three of the DCU (Comics) pairings also appear under "Batman (Comics)". "Batman (Comics)" is redundant and can be deleted.

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you so much!

[(Anonymous)]

There are two copies of this "Star Trek: Deep Space Nine" pairing:
- Julian Bashir/Miles O'Brien (DS9)
- Julian Bashir/Miles O'Brien (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)

"Ares/Hercules (H:TLJ)" appears under two fandoms (not sure which was intended):
- Hercules: The Legendary Journeys
- Xena: Warrior Princess

This pairing wandered into "No Fandom":
- Amber/Hei (Darker Than Black)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

I nommed H/C - Character with non-overeating-induced stomach pain gets belly rubbed and H/C - Sick/injured character is lovingly cared for and given tea and cuddles. If you want to change H/C to Hurt/Comfort for consistency with the other hurt/comfort tags, I'm good with that.

Link to my noms page, if you need it: https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/3515/nominations/138826

[hauntedshadow]

I changed it! Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicates in Crossover Fandom:
Diana (DCEU)/Thor (MCU)
Diana Prince (DCEU)/Thor (MCU)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[ashling]

duplicates in Man From UNCLE (the movie)
Illya Kuryakin/Napoleon Solo (MfU 2015)
Illya Kuryakin/Napoleon Solo (MUNCLE 2015)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[ashling]

this wandered into the No Fandom fandom:
Amber/Hei (Darker Than Black)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

There's a typo in Time Loop - Gan Only Be Broken When Everyone In The Group Survives To The End. "Gan" should be "Can".

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[eggsbenedict]

Duplicate in 逆転裁判 | Gyakuten Saiban | Ace Attorney:

Mitsurugi Reiji | Miles Edgeworth/Naruhodou Ryuuichi | Phoenix Wright (Ace Attorney)
Miles Edgeworth/Phoenix Wright (Ace Attorney)

The first one is canonical but the second one is easier to read - I didn't nominate them so maybe a nominator can weigh in with their preferences. ^^

[aris_tgd]

I nominated the canonical, so either a second person wanted to make sure the ship got in or it got oddly duped somehow. I don't have a preference!

[(Anonymous)]

Found a typo in Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones -

phraim/Seth (Fire Emblem: Sacred Stones) - should be Ephraim/Seth

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[learnedfoot]

Duplicate:

Peter Parker / Julien Spritzer (Mrs. Fletcher) is under MCU
Peter Parker (MCU)/Julian (Mrs. Fletcher) is under Crossover Fandom

These are the same ship. My understanding is that since it's a crossover it should be under crossovers?

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

There are some runaway relationship tags - judging from the disambiguation, it looks like the relationships with "MR:PMMM" under "Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magika | Puella Magi Madoka Magica" should be moved to "Magia Record: Puella Magi Madoka Magica Side Story."

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[sockmissedthewasher]

As one of the nominators for the "rape recovery" tag, I am glad you made this decision. I saw it put forth as one needing to be changed, but I didn't want mine changed to Hurt/Comfort because the character is dealing with it alone, no one is comforting them, so I'm glad you did not switch it. Thank you.

[hauntedshadow]

Ah, I'm so glad! The mission statement for this exchange is to get THAT EXACT THING!!! AND NOTHING ELSE WILL DO!!! I'm happy you get to be shamelessly specific.

[(Anonymous)]

I'm not certain because I didn't nominate either one, but I think these tags are the same thing:

Oh No They're Hot
Sudden Realization - Oh No They're Hot

Gonna be That Person

[aris_tgd]

'Character A's Past Bad Realtionship(s) Effect(s) Their Relationship With Character B' <-- Should this be 'Affects'? 'Effects' in this sentence would mean that the past bad relationship made their relationship with B come into being, where 'affects' means that the past bad relationship informs or makes changes to the A/B relationship.

English! It's the worst sometimes!

(Also "Relationship" appears to be misspelled in the tag)

Re: Gonna be That Person

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you! It's been fixed.

[(Anonymous)]

Bruce Wayn/Dick Grayson/Jason Todd (Titans TV) has a typo. It should be:
Bruce Wayne/Dick Grayson/Jason Todd (Titans TV)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Another typo: Big Though Man is a Mommy's Boy

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[relle]

There's a duplicate in The Witcher (TV):

Geralt z Rivii | Geralt of Rivia/Jaskier | Dandelion (The Witcher TV)
Geralt z Rivii/Jaskier (The Witcher)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[tigerlily]

There’s a duplicate in Star Trek: The Original Series:

James T. Kirk/Spock (ST: TOS)
James T. Kirk/Spock (Star Trek TOS)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

These two categories in the Movies section should be merged together:

Lord of the Rings (Movies) (7) ↑

Aragorn & Merry (LotR Movies)
Aragorn & Pippin (Lord of the Rings Movies)
Boromir & Merry (LotR Movies)
Boromir & Pippin (LotR Movies)
Eomer & Merry (LotR Movies)
Eomer & Pippin (LotR Movies)
Merry & Pippin (LotR Movies)

The Lord of the Rings (Movies) (1) ↑

Aragorn/Boromir (LotR Movies)

[(Anonymous)]

On the other hand, I nominated Aragorn/Boromir and I'm fine for it to stay separate if the mod has other priorities.

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate:

H/C - Sick/injured character is lovingly cared for and given tea and cuddles

Hurt/Comfort - Sick/injured character is lovingly cared for and given tea and cuddles

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicates in Dark Matter fandom:

The Android/Three | Marcus Boone/Two | Portia Lin (Dark Matter TV)
The Android/Two/Three (Dark Matter (TV))

One | Derrick Moss/Three | Marcus Boone (Dark Matter TV)
One/Three (Dark Matter (TV))

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate under Star Trek The Next Generation too:

Jean-Luc Picard/Q (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

Jean-Luc Picard/Q (TNG)

[hauntedshadow]

Thank you!