Fandom/Ship Clarification Post #1

[idficmod]

Reminders
- Remember to disambiguate all nominations with the full or abbreviated canon name.
- Please properly capitalize your nominations, including both character names and canon names in disambiguations.
- Do not use piping in nominations.
- Crossover ships need to be nominated under "Crossover Fandom."

Queries

Legend of Korra: Suyin Beifong & the Earth Kingdom(LoK)
What does "earth kingdom" entail? A sentient location? Any resident of Earth Kingdom? Specific people?

Coming Out on Top: Mark Matthews/Beau Melnick/Bradley "Brad" Melnick/Roman/the Orlin College men's football team (COoT)
Every member of the football team? Current members?

Kingsman: Gary "Eggsy" Unwin and Kingsman Support Staff (Kingsman Movies)
A specific group of canon characters? Original support staff character(s)?

Danny Phantom
There are several DCU/Danny Phantom crossover ships nominated under Danny Phantom. Please nominate these under the fandom "Crossover Fandom" instead.

Leverage (US TV 2008): Team Leverage & Harry Wilson (Leverage)
Is Team Leverage a defined group in canon?

A Song of Ice and Fire & Related Fandoms
Do not nominate under "& Related Fandoms." Please nominate under a more specific fandom.

Earth Girl Series - Janet Edwards: Jarra Tell Morrath & Beta Sector (Earth Girl Series), Jarra Tell Morrath & Tell Clan (Earth Girl Series)
Are Beta Sector and Tell Clan a specific group or person? Can they be defined more specifically?

A Practical Guide to Evil - erraticerrata: Catherine Foundling & the people of Callow (APGTE)
"The people of Callow" is very broad, please be more specific.

Dark (TV 2017): Noah/Noah (Dark)
Is this two canon characters, or a request for selfcest?

Crossover Fandom: Lt Columbo (Columbo) & Batfamily Members (DCU)
Please be more specific; "Batfamily Members" is not a defined group.

Crossover Fandom: Lt Columbo (Columbo) & The Roy Family (Succession)
Everyone in the Roy family? Specific members?

Rapunzel's Tangled Adventure (Cartoon): Separatists of Saporia & Varian (Tangled); Separatists of Saporia/Varian (Tangled); The Brotherhood & Varian (Tangled)
Are the Separatists of Saporia and The Brotherhood specific groups of characters?

Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. (TV): Agents of SHIELD Team & Lincoln Campbell (AoS); Hive & Lincoln Campbell (AoS); HYDRA & Lincoln Campbell (AoS)
Is the Agents of SHIELD Team a specific group of characters?

Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series): Anthro!Obstagoon/Piers (PKMN MVGS)
What is meant by "anthro" here?

Our Flag Means Death: Crew of the Revenge & Israel Hands (OFMD); Crew of the Revenge/Israel Hands (OFMD)
Too broad of a group; please be more specific.

Remove piping from the following fandoms:
Bodies (TV 2023)
镇魂 | Guardian (TV 2018)
Once Upon a Time (TV)
僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga)
The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien
Empires SMP
Gothic (1986)
Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series)

Comments

Re: Coming Out on Top

[flowersforgraves]

Not the mod but a tag minion. Would "Mark Matthews/Beau Melnick/Bradley "Brad" Melnick/Roman/Any Other Orlin Football Players (COoT)" work for you? It's more a question of trying to make it narrow enough so creators don't feel like they need to include every single member of the team.

Re: Coming Out on Top

[lleullawgyffes]

yes, that would work! maybe make it "Player(s)" just to give as much flexibility as possible.