Fandom/Ship Clarification Post #2
Feb. 27th, 2024 09:54 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Find the final fandom/ship related queries below. Responses to this post will be accepted for 24 hours, after which we will change or reject any remaining pending nominations, and then sign-ups will open. That being said, sign-ups will be opening a day late to allow time for responses to this post (separate post about the delay to follow).
General Queries
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. (TV): HYDRA & Lincoln Campbell (AoS)
We will change this to "Any HYDRA Member(s) & Lincoln Campbell" unless the nominator feels this meaningfully changes the tag.
DC Extended Universe: Diana (Wonder Woman)/Alfred Pennyworth (DCEU), Diana (Wonder Woman)/Barbara Minerva (DCEU), Diana (Wonder Woman)/Harleen Quinzel (DCEU), Diana (Wonder Woman)/Lois Lane (DCEU)
Are these meant to go under Crossover Fandom, or is "(Wonder Woman)" being used to clarify who Diana is? If this is the case, can "Diana (Wonder Woman)" be changed to just "Wonder Woman"?
Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling: Harry Potter/Multiple female characters
We will change this to "Harry Potter/Any Two or More Female Characters" unless the nominator feels this meaningfully changes the tag.
Marvel Cinematic Universe: Avengers Team Members (MCU)
We will change this to "Any Two or More Avengers Team Members (MCU)" unless the nominator feels this meaningfully changes the tag.
A Song of Ice and Fire & Related Fandoms: Aemond Targaryen/Lucerys Velaryon (ASoIaF & related)
ASOIAF and GOT are both already in the tagset. Please choose one, if there is no response we will change it to ASOIAF.
Assassin's Creed - All Media Types
We'd like to avoid AMT fandoms where possible--can this be changed to Assassin's Creed Games?
Danny Phantom: Danny Fenton & Justice League (DCU), Danny Fenton/Jason Todd
These are crossover ships and should go under Crossover Fandom. We will move them, but there are multiple iterations of the Justice League and Jason Todd--please clarify how these should be disambiguated.
DCU: Batfamily Members & Justice League & Members of the Team (Young Justice) & Bruce Wayne, Billy Batson & Bruce Wayne, Billy Batson & Clark Kent, Billy Batson & Justice League, Clark Kent & Kon-El | Conner Kent, Clark Kent & Lex Luthor, Clark Kent/Bruce Wayne, Clark Kent/Lex Luthor, Tim Drake & Dick Grayson & Jason Todd & Bruce Wayne & Damian Wayne, Tim Drake/Kon-El | Conner Kent
Can these go under "DCU (Comics)" which is already in the tagset?
Fate/stay night & Related Fandoms
We'd like to avoid "& Related Fandoms" where possible--can this be changed?
Marvel (Comics): Steve Rogers/Tony Stark (616), Steve Rogers/Tony Stark (Ultimates)
Marvel (Comics) contains disambiguations for both 616 and Ultimates--should these be split into two fandoms or is it okay for them to both be under Marvel (Comics)?
Marvel (Comics): Tony Stark/Tony Stark
Is this referring to a canonical double or universe crossing, or something else?
Star Wars - All Media Types (Original Characters): Original Male Hutt/Any Female Non-Hutt Character (SWOC), Original Male Hutt/Original Human Female Bounty Hunter (SWOC), Original Male Hutt/Original Twi'lek Dancing Girl (SWOC)
We'd like to avoid AMT fandoms where possible. Can this be changed to "Star Wars (Movies)"?
Terror Train - All Media Types
We'd like to avoid AMT fandoms where possible. Can this be changed?
XCOM (Video Games) & Related Fandoms
We'd like to avoid "& Related Fandoms" where possible. Can this be changed?
Piping Issues
The nomination rules disallow piping. Please provide guidance for which of the piped names to delete if you are the nominator or are familiar with the fandom. If there is no response, we will arbitrarily choose one name to delete.
Assassin's Creed: Rashid ad-Din Sinan | Al Mualim
DC's Arrowverse: Alura In-Ze | Alura Zor-El (Arrowverse)
Crossover Fandom: Gabriel Lorca | Mirror Gabriel Lorca (SW: D), Lorne | Krevlornswath (AtS)
Hazbin Hotel: Charlie Magne | Morningstar
Homestuck: Dave's Bro | Beta Dirk Strider, The Psiioniic | The Helmsman, The Signless | The Sufferer
Marvel Cinematic Universe: Brunnhilde | Valkyrie
Miraculous Ladybug: Adrien Agreste | Chat Noir, Marinette Dupain-Cheng | Ladybug, Alternate Adrien Agreste | Claw Noir, Alternate Marinette Dupain-Cheng | Shadybug
Found (TV): Sir | Hugh Evans
The Hazards of Love (Webcomic): Fawn | Amparo Uribe
Warbreaker - Brandon Sanderson: Denth | VaraTreledees
Warhammer 40.000: Rogue Trader (Video Game): Female Rogue Trader | Lord Captain
General Queries
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. (TV): HYDRA & Lincoln Campbell (AoS)
We will change this to "Any HYDRA Member(s) & Lincoln Campbell" unless the nominator feels this meaningfully changes the tag.
DC Extended Universe: Diana (Wonder Woman)/Alfred Pennyworth (DCEU), Diana (Wonder Woman)/Barbara Minerva (DCEU), Diana (Wonder Woman)/Harleen Quinzel (DCEU), Diana (Wonder Woman)/Lois Lane (DCEU)
Are these meant to go under Crossover Fandom, or is "(Wonder Woman)" being used to clarify who Diana is? If this is the case, can "Diana (Wonder Woman)" be changed to just "Wonder Woman"?
Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling: Harry Potter/Multiple female characters
We will change this to "Harry Potter/Any Two or More Female Characters" unless the nominator feels this meaningfully changes the tag.
Marvel Cinematic Universe: Avengers Team Members (MCU)
We will change this to "Any Two or More Avengers Team Members (MCU)" unless the nominator feels this meaningfully changes the tag.
A Song of Ice and Fire & Related Fandoms: Aemond Targaryen/Lucerys Velaryon (ASoIaF & related)
ASOIAF and GOT are both already in the tagset. Please choose one, if there is no response we will change it to ASOIAF.
Assassin's Creed - All Media Types
We'd like to avoid AMT fandoms where possible--can this be changed to Assassin's Creed Games?
Danny Phantom: Danny Fenton & Justice League (DCU), Danny Fenton/Jason Todd
These are crossover ships and should go under Crossover Fandom. We will move them, but there are multiple iterations of the Justice League and Jason Todd--please clarify how these should be disambiguated.
DCU: Batfamily Members & Justice League & Members of the Team (Young Justice) & Bruce Wayne, Billy Batson & Bruce Wayne, Billy Batson & Clark Kent, Billy Batson & Justice League, Clark Kent & Kon-El | Conner Kent, Clark Kent & Lex Luthor, Clark Kent/Bruce Wayne, Clark Kent/Lex Luthor, Tim Drake & Dick Grayson & Jason Todd & Bruce Wayne & Damian Wayne, Tim Drake/Kon-El | Conner Kent
Can these go under "DCU (Comics)" which is already in the tagset?
Fate/stay night & Related Fandoms
We'd like to avoid "& Related Fandoms" where possible--can this be changed?
Marvel (Comics): Steve Rogers/Tony Stark (616), Steve Rogers/Tony Stark (Ultimates)
Marvel (Comics) contains disambiguations for both 616 and Ultimates--should these be split into two fandoms or is it okay for them to both be under Marvel (Comics)?
Marvel (Comics): Tony Stark/Tony Stark
Is this referring to a canonical double or universe crossing, or something else?
Star Wars - All Media Types (Original Characters): Original Male Hutt/Any Female Non-Hutt Character (SWOC), Original Male Hutt/Original Human Female Bounty Hunter (SWOC), Original Male Hutt/Original Twi'lek Dancing Girl (SWOC)
We'd like to avoid AMT fandoms where possible. Can this be changed to "Star Wars (Movies)"?
Terror Train - All Media Types
We'd like to avoid AMT fandoms where possible. Can this be changed?
XCOM (Video Games) & Related Fandoms
We'd like to avoid "& Related Fandoms" where possible. Can this be changed?
Piping Issues
The nomination rules disallow piping. Please provide guidance for which of the piped names to delete if you are the nominator or are familiar with the fandom. If there is no response, we will arbitrarily choose one name to delete.
Assassin's Creed: Rashid ad-Din Sinan | Al Mualim
DC's Arrowverse: Alura In-Ze | Alura Zor-El (Arrowverse)
Crossover Fandom: Gabriel Lorca | Mirror Gabriel Lorca (SW: D), Lorne | Krevlornswath (AtS)
Hazbin Hotel: Charlie Magne | Morningstar
Homestuck: Dave's Bro | Beta Dirk Strider, The Psiioniic | The Helmsman, The Signless | The Sufferer
Marvel Cinematic Universe: Brunnhilde | Valkyrie
Miraculous Ladybug: Adrien Agreste | Chat Noir, Marinette Dupain-Cheng | Ladybug, Alternate Adrien Agreste | Claw Noir, Alternate Marinette Dupain-Cheng | Shadybug
Found (TV): Sir | Hugh Evans
The Hazards of Love (Webcomic): Fawn | Amparo Uribe
Warbreaker - Brandon Sanderson: Denth | VaraTreledees
Warhammer 40.000: Rogue Trader (Video Game): Female Rogue Trader | Lord Captain